Report urges action on human rights and the devolution framework
- Area of Work: Policy and Research
- Type: News Item
- Published: 19th April 2024
Amendments to the Scotland Act are necessary to ensure the Scottish Parliament can fully incorporate human rights in devolved areas.
A new report published by the Human Rights Consortium Scotland (HRCS) has set out the range of options available to maximise the scope of the upcoming Human Rights Bill. The paper, by Professor Aileen McHarg, Professor in Public Law and Human Rights at Durham University, highlights the significant negative implications that the Supreme Court decision on the United Nations Convention on Rights of the Child (UNCRC) Bill has for the incorporation of human rights in devolved areas.
In October 2021, the Supreme Court ruled that parts of the UNCRC Bill were outside the Scottish Parliament’s powers, and that the duties under the Bill could not be applied to Acts of the UK Parliament relating to devolved issues. This required the Scottish Government to amend the Bill and bring it back to Parliament for reconsideration, with the amended Bill passing unanimously in December 2023.
A significant amount of relevant legislation, notably the Children (Scotland) Act 1995, pre-dates devolution and therefore fell out of the scope of the amended UNCRC Bill (now Act). In the paper, Professor McHarg describes the Supreme Court’s decision as “incoherent” and a “wholly unexpected” limitation on the Scottish Parliament’s powers, and the final form of the UNCRC Act as “narrower”, “much more complicated” and “essentially arbitrary” in scope.
The upcoming Human Rights Bill is similarly constrained by this decision, with acts including the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 and National Health (Scotland) Act 1978 leaving key human rights areas outwith the scope of the Bill. Professor McHarg’s recommended solution is for the UK Government to amend the Scotland Act to reverse the effect of the Supreme Court decision, either by deleting the relevant section entirely, or adding a new section that clarifies the powers of the Scottish Parliament.
The paper also sets out alternative solutions to widen the scope of the Human Rights Bill, but considers many of these to be risky, such as extending procedural duties, or time consuming, for example consolidating existing UK Parliament originated legislation into new Scottish Parliament legislation.
The ALLIANCE strongly supports a maximalist approach to human rights incorporation in Scotland, and are particularly concerned at the potential limitations on incorporating the UN Convention on the Rights of Disabled People (UNCRPD). We urge both the UK and Scottish Governments to carefully consider Professor McHarg’s paper, and all parties to commit to ensuring that the Human Rights Bill has the widest possible scope to protect and uphold everyone’s rights in law.
You can read the full report on the HRCS website here.
End of page.
You may also like:
The Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) has published a report on the state of economic, social and cultural rights in Scotland.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcomes the proposed strategy, though a Human Rights Bill is necessary for full effect.
Continue readingObesity Action Scotland wants to stop unhealthy food sponsorship at Scottish sports events including the 2026 Glasgow Commonwealth Games.
Continue readingResidents of Leith’s famous Banana Flats (Cables Wynd House) have launched their human rights monitoring report.
Continue readingThe Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) report finds troubling failures in progress from institutionalisation to independent living.
Continue readingThe updated SPSO Principles demonstrate a positive shift towards putting people and their human rights at the centre of complaints handling.
Continue readingThe Mental Welfare Commission calls for urgent changes so people with learning disability and complex needs can leave hospital and flourish.
Continue readingMinister announces parts of the National Care Service Bill will be dropped due to a lack of compromise and support.
Continue readingAre you aged 55+, living in the UK, and interested in supporting new research?
Continue readingWe have submitted a parallel report to the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights for its examination of rights in the UK.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcome the aims of widening access to palliative care, but actions must be underpinned by resources and accountability.
Continue readingAutistic Knowledge Development and National Autistic Society Scotland celebrate the success of the Embrace Autism programme.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE wants to hear from you if you have experienced barriers to accessing Self-Directed Support.
Continue readingThe First Minister has reiterated his commitment to the continuation of Contact Scotland BSL.
Continue readingThe Policy and Public Affairs programme influenced government policy in many areas over 2024.
Continue readingRaising awareness of key areas of women’s health, challenging myths and stigma through positive dialogue, and lived experience forums.
Continue readingWhilst the draft Covenant is a positive start, it is unclear how it's aims will be realised in practice.
Continue readingWho Cares? Scotland publishes their third Lifelong Rights Issue Paper on Belonging and Connections.
Continue readingSHRC publishes State of the Nation report examining the civil and political rights of all people in Scotland.
Continue readingFill out a survey to share your experiences as a single parent in accessing higher education.
Continue readingALLIANCE signs joint letter calling on political leaders to reaffirm UK commitment to human rights obligations on Human Rights Day 2024.
Continue readingGMC Scotland have published a new report which analyses trends in the medical workforce across the UK.
Continue readingThe government is working with Public Health Scotland to support NHS Boards to operate as effective 'Anchor' institutions.
Continue readingHave your say in Public Health Scotland's (PHS) equality outcome consultation.
Continue readingNHS Education for Scotland (NES) are currently consulting on their equality outcomes for 2025-29.
Continue reading