The National Audiology Review – is Scotland failing deaf children?
- Written by: Mark Ballard — National Deaf Children's Society — Head of Policy for Scotland
- Published: 6th November 2023

Mark Ballard outlines writes that it is time for the Scottish Government to act on the National Audiology Review
Serious failings in support for deaf children have been laid bare in the final report of the Independent Review of Audiology Services in Scotland. Mark Ballard outlines the history of the Review, and suggests that it is time for the Scottish Government to act on the recommendations of the report.
In 2018, parents raised concerns with the National Deaf Children’s Society about their experience of Lothian’s Children’s Audiology Services. This eventually led to a complaint being raised by a parent with the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman, who upheld it, and NHS Lothian agreed to carry out an urgent review of its services.
The British Academy of Audiology (BAA) was commissioned to carry out an audit of NHS Lothian’s paediatric audiology caseload from 2009-2018. This included nearly 23,000 children, of which the BAA sampled just over a thousand records. The results were damning.
The full findings were revealed in a report published in December 2021. Only 120 of the records the BAA examined raised no concerns at all. However, in 155 of the records, the concerns were “significant”, with some shocking stories of children’s deafness not being identified, of parents not being believed, and opportunities for medical intervention missed. It found that the average age of children identified as deaf under NHS Lothian was four and half years old, compared to just over three months, on average, in services in England. The report concluded that this massive discrepancy appeared to have gone “unreported and un-noticed.”
Some of those children suffered life-changing consequences: waiting years to be provided with hearing aids; being diagnosed too late to have vital hearing implant surgery, which would have allowed them access to sound; not having the chance to use sign language from an early age. The National Deaf Children’s Society continues to work with Families Failed by Lothian Audiology Action Group, to try to ensure that these children are not failed again by a lack of ongoing support.
Having worked with parents to expose the failings at NHS Lothian, and after considering the horrendous findings of that report, the National Deaf Children’s Society called on the Scottish Government to launch an urgent and sweeping review of children’s hearing departments across Scotland. The review ran for about a year from spring 2022 to spring 2023, with the final report and recommendations published in August 2023.
We are grateful that the Independent National Review was carried out, but the findings of the review show there are serious issues affecting audiology services across the country. Without urgent action, more deaf children will be failed.
The review found “multiple, systemic problems affecting audiology services in NHS Scotland”, including an “absence of national leadership, strategic planning and workforce planning” and that there had been “no quality assurance of services” in recent years.
A lack of consistent data collection across Scotland means it is difficult to monitor quality and compare how health boards are performing. The most alarming recommendations the review identified are around the auditory brainstem response (ABR) testing, carried out to identify deafness in very young children, and ensuring hearing aids are properly fitted. The review identified an urgent need for training to improve the quality of ABR testing at every health board in Scotland. We want to see urgent action to address this problem.
There is also cross-sector consensus that we must increase the number of paediatric audiologists. Scotland urgently needs a graduate level audiology programme to help address the national shortage of audiologists, as well as a fast-track route into the profession for those other relevant qualifications.
We also know that morale amongst audiologists is at rock bottom, with workforce shortages, lack of training, and staff feeling that they are being pushed to do more with few resources, while feeling they are being blamed for a situation they cannot improve. Increasing numbers of audiologists are on long term sick leave with stress or opting to leave the profession completely.
We are still waiting for the response from the Scottish Government to the recommendations in the report, six years after concerns were raised about NHS Lothian, and nearly two years since the BAA report.
The bottom line is that there must be change. We know that deaf children can achieve anything that hearing children can when they get the right support, but for this to happen their deafness must be identified at the earliest opportunity and they must always receive high quality and effective support.
That’s why NDCS are calling on ministers to act now, to ensure parents can be certain their deaf child is receiving the support they need. Parents have a right to know that if there are concerns about their child’s hearing that they will have a specialist hearing test undertaken at the right time, carried out by an appropriately trained audiologist. Parents need to be reassured that the audiology department they rely on is properly staffed and has the equipment it needs. The Scottish Government and NHS boards know what they need to do. We hope the Scottish Parliament holds them to account on the delivery of the recommendations.
End of page.
You may also like:
Louise shares her thoughts on the need for a statutory right to lifelong, independent advocacy.
Continue readingALISS is supporting GCHSCP's work to help people live independent lives by connecting them to support in their local community.
Continue readingKairos Women+ share the vital foundations of their creative anti-stigma work with women.
Continue readingToo many carers simply cannot make ends meet, but a Minimum Income Guarantee could be the solution.
Continue readingNational Stalking Awareness Week 2025, from 21-25 April, will focus on healthcare professionals spotting the signs of stalking.
Continue readingCOPE Scotland have developed a suite of resources to rebuild confidence and self-belief, crucial components of mental wellbeing.
Continue readingCuts to disability payments by the UK government are all the more worrying for lack of information on devolution impacts in Scotland.
Continue readingTo improve outcomes for children and young people, we must consider how we can build on GIRFEC for the future.
Continue readingHow funding community-led participatory creative projects can shine a light on intersectional stigma
Maeve reflects on the Anti-Stigma Arts fund and how community-led projects can lead the way in tackling stigma.
Continue readingThe role of museums in promoting community engagement, health, and education was a major theme of the discussions throughout the day.
Continue readingAt the ALLIANCE we believe that accessibility is a gateway to human rights.
Continue readingLorraine Glass, Director at respectme, reflects on the vital work they do to reduce bullying and improve wellbeing.
Continue reading“Before, when I thought about what happened, something inside me was stuck. Now, after sharing my story I feel lighter, and more free”.
Continue readingSustainable funding can unlock the transformative power of creative engagement for tackling stigma.
Continue readingTo build a positive culture of human rights, everyone needs to know and be aware of their rights.
Continue readingEveryone deserves a safe and affordable home - Scotland must act now to make housing a human right for all.
Continue reading'What Matters to You?' is a question that transforms live through kindness and compassion. Read the story of Napier House in Fife.
Continue readingHuman rights are the path to a fairer, stronger Scotland; each step we take today helps to shape our future.
Continue readingThe Charter of Rights for People who live with and experience issues around substance use is about to be launched.
Continue readingSimple GDP growth alone does not deliver a fair, human rights respecting society and public services.
Continue readingHeidi Tweedie, Jane Miller and Dr Patty Lozano-Casal reflect on the need to end mental health stigma and discrimination in healthcare.
Continue readingThe benefits of collaborative analysis approaches and why more should embark on this process.
Continue readingHilda Campbell shares COPE Scotland's thoughts and ideas for keeping well and improving your wellbeing during the winter months.
Continue readingAs the Self Management Network Scotland reaches 1,000 members, Joanne McCoy, Manager at MySelf-Management reflects on the network's value.
Continue readingJohn Watson, Associate Director of Stroke Association Scotland, shares how vital investment into stroke care is.
Continue reading