Economic, Social and Cultural Human Rights Failures in the Highlands and Islands
- Area of Work: Policy and Research
- Type: News Item
- Published: 27th November 2024
The Scottish Human Rights Commission have published a report on all economic, social and cultural rights in the Highlands and Islands.
The Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) have published a report looking at the realisation of all economic, social and cultural (ESC) rights in the Highlands and Islands. ESC rights are necessary to live a life free from fear and want. These include the right to housing, food, health and social security.
The report gathers the lived experiences of people and communities heard during visits to the Highlands and Islands. It also includes desk-based research and analysis of human rights complaints to MSPs and the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman. This work aimed to fill gaps in human rights evidence bases and raise awareness of human rights issues in these areas with decision makers, showing the need for a geographically specific approach to Scottish law and policy.
Some of the most critical issues that we found are the apparent failures to meet the most basic international obligations related to the right to food, the right to housing, the right to health, and the right to cultural life.
By listening to the lived experiences of residents and organisations in the area, as well as through human rights treaty monitoring work, the SHRC identified specific issues affecting rural and island communities, such as:
- Slow and inaccessible health care services
- Lack of affordable housing
- Limited access to sufficient and nutritious food
- Poverty related gaps in education
- Limited access to technology and poor internet connectivity
- Fuel poverty
Concerningly, it was reported by rights holders that there is an apparent regression or deterioration of rights across the Highlands and Islands. This is exacerbated by decisions on budget reductions or the complete elimination of previously existing services, without sufficient mitigating measures.
Across all rights examined, there is not a single human right that meets all the conditions of adequacy under international law. This means that there are significant failures in how policies and services are being designed and/or delivered and services across the Highlands and Islands are not fully accessible, affordable, available, acceptable, or of sufficient quality (among other conditions).
As a result, the SHRC has issued recommendations to the Scottish Government and duty bearers to ensure there is full compliance with Scotland’s international human rights obligations.
Read the Executive Summary of the report. Or, read the report in full here.
End of page.
You may also like:
The annual survey by Carers UK helps to shape campaigns and policy work, based on the experiences of unpaid carers.
Continue readingThe Practice Learning Review Consultation will remain open until 23 July 2026
Continue readingMulti-year funding was at the centre of the Scottish Parliament debate on a Third Sector Partnership Agreement
Continue readingThe letter urges honesty on the financial challenges facing Scotland, and progressing reforms to council tax.
Continue readingALLIANCE consultation response calls for clearer guidance, sustained investment and local support to make carers' breaks a reality.
Continue readingThe letter also calls on the Scottish Government to appoint a dedicated Cabinet Secretary for Human Rights.
Continue readingThe letter calls on the UK Government to take steps to fully incorporate economic, social and cultural rights in law.
Continue readingParties set out positions on human rights, social care and more at our hustings ahead of the 2026 Scottish Parliament Election.
Continue readingAfter the Scottish Government scrapped the initial review, the most recent proposal suggests a smaller number of broader outcomes.
Continue readingYoung people’s feedback will help NHS 24 better understand needs and improve support services.
Continue readingALLIANCE input and lived experience evidence help shape stronger, person-centred and trauma-informed maternity care
Continue readingSupporting stronger information rights, while warning delivery must work for an already stretched sector
Continue readingA new resource by Adaptation Scotland to help social care professionals integrate climate adaptation into care planning and delivery.
Continue readingRead more about the ALLIANCE response to the report on the impact of COVID-19 on the health and social care sector in Scotland.
Continue readingUp to £20 million to be delivered via Independent Living Fund to help people live in their communities
Continue readingRefined plans focus on practical measure to improve outcomes for people with learning disabilities, autism and neurodivergence.
Continue readingMarie Curie has published new analysis showing that almost one in three people in Scotland die without the palliative care they need.
Continue readingThis budget must put the third sector on a sustainable footing, and deliver on the Government's pledge to abolish social care charges.
Continue readingShare your views before 19 February
Continue readingReform of the council tax system is long overdue, with the current system negatively impacting funding for services including social care.
Continue readingFirst monitoring report shows improvements in wellbeing and services alongside ongoing gaps in data and unequal outcomes
Continue readingProgress in many areas is welcome, but the budget must go further on social care, mental health and third sector support.
Continue readingThe 'joint statement on prevention' partners have issued a follow-up ahead of the 2026-27 Scottish Budget.
Continue readingEvent calls for human rights to be a priority ahead of the Scottish Parliament Elections in 2026.
Continue readingCommission raises concerns over the state of economic, social and cultural rights in Scotland
Continue reading