Economic, Social and Cultural Human Rights Failures in the Highlands and Islands
- Area of Work: Policy and Research
- Type: News Item
- Published: 27th November 2024
The Scottish Human Rights Commission have published a report on all economic, social and cultural rights in the Highlands and Islands.
The Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) have published a report looking at the realisation of all economic, social and cultural (ESC) rights in the Highlands and Islands. ESC rights are necessary to live a life free from fear and want. These include the right to housing, food, health and social security.
The report gathers the lived experiences of people and communities heard during visits to the Highlands and Islands. It also includes desk-based research and analysis of human rights complaints to MSPs and the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman. This work aimed to fill gaps in human rights evidence bases and raise awareness of human rights issues in these areas with decision makers, showing the need for a geographically specific approach to Scottish law and policy.
Some of the most critical issues that we found are the apparent failures to meet the most basic international obligations related to the right to food, the right to housing, the right to health, and the right to cultural life.
By listening to the lived experiences of residents and organisations in the area, as well as through human rights treaty monitoring work, the SHRC identified specific issues affecting rural and island communities, such as:
- Slow and inaccessible health care services
- Lack of affordable housing
- Limited access to sufficient and nutritious food
- Poverty related gaps in education
- Limited access to technology and poor internet connectivity
- Fuel poverty
Concerningly, it was reported by rights holders that there is an apparent regression or deterioration of rights across the Highlands and Islands. This is exacerbated by decisions on budget reductions or the complete elimination of previously existing services, without sufficient mitigating measures.
Across all rights examined, there is not a single human right that meets all the conditions of adequacy under international law. This means that there are significant failures in how policies and services are being designed and/or delivered and services across the Highlands and Islands are not fully accessible, affordable, available, acceptable, or of sufficient quality (among other conditions).
As a result, the SHRC has issued recommendations to the Scottish Government and duty bearers to ensure there is full compliance with Scotland’s international human rights obligations.
Read the Executive Summary of the report. Or, read the report in full here.
End of page.
You may also like:
NHS Education for Scotland (NES) are currently consulting on their equality outcomes for 2025-29.
Continue readingOrganisations across Scotland are urging the Scottish Government to prioritise the Scottish Human Rights Bill.
Continue readingA report from the Royal Pharmaceutical Society calls for governments across the UK to work on a strategy to manage medicine shortages.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcomes the announcement of a new statutory levy to tackle gambling harms.
Continue readingWe want to hear from members about our draft report to the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights about rights in Scotland.
Continue readingOur briefing ahead of the 2025-26 Scottish Budget calls for a human rights based approach to funding and delivering services.
Continue readingLet's Be Heard will finish gathering experiences of the pandemic in Scotland on 29 November 2024.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE is hosting several events across December - February in support of the Scottish Government's Women's Health Plan.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE have joined a new campaign group urging action on fair taxation to fund essential services including health and social care.
Continue readingEdinburgh researchers are set to examine the perspectives of deaf survivors of domestic abuse, focusing on how this trauma affects families.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE signs joint letter to the Scottish Government on reinstating the Scottish Fuel Insecurity Fund.
Continue readingCentre for Care and Carers UK publish research report on the value of unpaid carers in the UK.
Continue readingHealthcare Improvement Scotland have published Ageing and Frailty Standards for the Care of Older People.
Continue readingThe report notes the focus on the wellbeing economy in the National Outcomes differs from the First Minister's priority for economic growth.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE shares our disappointment that the NCS Bill has been delayed, and that it may be scrapped.
Continue readingThe Social Justice and Social Security Committee published a report on third sector funding principles as part of the pre-budget scrutiny.
Continue readingRecent Independent Report assesses the challenges facing NHS England and makes recommendations relevant to Scotland.
Continue readingKidney Research are calling on the Scottish Government to commit to turn the tide on kidney disease.
Continue readingThis final report on the Women's Health Plan 2021 to 2024 provides a summary of progress made.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcomes the reintroduction of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill by the UK Government after committing to it in their manifesto.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE has been working with Scottish Government to deliver activity on women’s health.
Continue readingThe interim report sets out initial findings, early actions that can be taken, and the themes that may be explored in the second stage.
Continue readingThe Chancellor set out her tax and spend plans, which include further changes to social security and some funding for Scotland.
Continue readingAudit Scotland has published its latest report on Alcohol and drug services.
Continue readingThe Care Inspectorate are currently looking for feedback on their Equality Outcomes for 2025-2029.
Continue reading