ALLIANCE express concerns over lack of clear evidence base for Winter Fuel Payment decision
- Area of Work: The ALLIANCE
- Type: News Item
- Published: 13th September 2024

The ALLIANCE are concerned by the impacts on older people, lack of transparent impact assessments, and role of devolution.
The ALLIANCE share the deep concern across the third sector about the recent UK Government decision to restrict the eligibility for the Winter Fuel Payment from anyone in receipt of the state pension to those receiving Pension Credit. Pension Credit uptake is relatively low at 63% and there is a “cliff-edge” to eligibility, where income of even £1 over the threshold removes entitlement entirely. This will mean the withdrawal of essential financial support from many older people at the time they most need it, as fuel bills are set to increase again.
Whilst we recognise that there is a difficult financial situation facing both the UK and Scottish Governments, it is vital that decisions are rooted in respect for human rights and do not exacerbate existing income and health inequalities. Reports that the UK Government will not publish any relevant impact assessments that informed their decision are worrying, and it would be particularly disappointing if no such assessments had been conducted at all.
We are also concerned about the knock-on effect this has had on the devolved Pension Age Winter Heating Payment (PAWHP) which is due to replace the WFP in Scotland this winter. Following the UK Government’s decision to significantly reduce the availability of the payment, the Scottish Government announced that due to the consequential reduction in their own available funding, they considered themselves to have no choice but to follow suit.
In our response to the PAWHP consultation the ALLIANCE supported maintaining the universal nature of the payment, which ensured high uptake of WFP without the need to apply or to administer a costly and potentially complex system of means testing. We have previously, for example in our response to the previous UK Government’s “Modernising support for independent living” green paper, noted that current arrangements between the two governments in relation to social security risks forcing the Scottish Government to take decisions against their own policy preferences and intentions.
The ALLIANCE would encourage the UK Government to publish any impact assessments it may have undertaken to inform their decision as a matter of transparency. We also call on the UK Government to work with the Scottish Government to review the fiscal framework, particularly as it relates to social security payments, to ensure that devolution of such payments allows for meaningful, independent decision making on the part of the Scottish Government. In addition, both governments should commit to taking a human rights budgeting approach to all public spending decisions, to ensure they do not negatively impact those already on the lowest incomes or with the poorest health.
End of page.
You may also like:
A new project will help unpaid carers across Scotland have a real say in the decisions and services that affect them.
Continue readingResearcher seeks young people and third sector staff for focus groups on what makes youth policy participation effective.
Continue readingTake part in testing MyCare.scot to ensure it is accessible for people living with sight, hearing, mobility and learning conditions.
Continue readingPsoriasis UK has launched its new position paper, setting patient-defined principles for improving 'rapid access' to psoriasis care.
Continue readingDiscover how QuestPhysio’s AI analytics platform connects Scottish physio clinics with advanced hardware to improve care.
Continue readingJoin our workshops as we aim to deliver the programme of community and lived experience engagement on AMR and IPC.
Continue readingHave your say on Audit Scotland's BSL priorities and actions.
Continue readingLived experience opportunity in Edinburgh.
Continue readingApply for up to £10,000 to support projects for deaf children and their families.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE Scottish Sensory Hub continue as Secretariat for the CPGD
Continue readingConcerns raised for people who are Deaf, Deafblind or who have Visual Impairments.
Continue reading#TryAToolTuesday raises awareness of free and trusted apps and resources that help people improve and manage their health and wellbeing.
Continue readingRead about the impact of genuine power sharing and lived experience led change.
Continue readingPeople's COVID-19 experiences show why rights must be better protected in future pandemics and emergencies.
Continue reading#TryAToolTuesday raises awareness of free and trusted apps and resources that help people improve and manage their health and wellbeing.
Continue readingLearn more about the hidden impact of mild and unilateral Deafness.
Continue readingNew research finds people are ready for honest conversations about how to bridge the “reality gap” of health and social care reform.
Continue readingNew research finds people are ready for honest conversations about how to bridge the “reality gap” of health and social care reform.
Continue readingChief Officer of Development Sara Redmond will represent the ALLIANCE through the process of developing the agreement.
Continue readingThe Scotland Reducing Gambling Harm (ScotRGH) programme has awarded new grants totalling £375,000 to 19 projects across Scotland
Continue readingA newly identified security vulnerability affecting PHP software used by millions of websites worldwide requires immediate attention.
Continue readingFind out more about this pilot service for BSL users in Scotland.
Continue readingA phased campaign supports earlier CKD recognition, helping healthcare professionals deliver timely care and improve patient outcomes.
Continue readingOur response warns that Scotland cannot achieve a sustainable health & care system without greater investment in prevention and social care
Continue readingScottish Women and Girls in Sport Week 2026, organised by Active Scotland, runs 2-8 November.
Continue reading