National Care Service Bill Stage 2 Call for Views – ALLIANCE response
- Area of Work: Policy and Research, Social Care
- Type: News Item
- Published: 17th September 2024
The ALLIANCE support the principles of a National Care Service however the Bill requires substantial amendments to deliver what people need.
The ALLIANCE has submitted a response to the National Care Service Bill Stage 2 Call for Views highlighting our member’s feedback on the proposed amendments.
The ALLIANCE welcomes the Committee giving people and organisations an opportunity to comment on the Scottish Government’s draft Stage 2 amendments through the Call for Views. Although this is unusual and represents a departure from usual Parliamentary procedure, it is appropriate due to the significant changes since the Bill was introduced.
We support the principle of the creation of a National Care Service. The NCS offers an opportunity to improve people’s experiences of rights based, person centred social care – if designed and implemented in a way that responds to the concerns and experiences of people accessing social care and the workforce, and the recommendations in the Independent Review of Adult Social Care.
However, we believe that the Bill as introduced requires substantial amendments at Stage 2 if it is to deliver improvements to the rights based, person centred social care that people need.
As detailed in this response, whilst a number of the Scottish Government’s amendments are welcome, they would not fully deliver these improvements. We are concerned that three years on from the original Scottish Government consultation, and more than two years since the Bill was introduced, a considerable amount of detail of how the NCS would operate in practice remains unclear. Our members have consistently reported difficulty in engaging with the Bill, due to this lack of detail and clarity.
The ALLIANCE participated in the Scottish Government’s Expert Legislative Advisory Group which provided comment ahead of the publication of the draft Stage 2 amendments. However, as we told the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee, we would want to take the opportunity to make it clear that our participation should not be taken as an indication that we are necessarily supportive of all the Scottish Government amendments or have co-designed them. We did not have sight of the text of the amendments prior to them being shared with the Committee, and this response should be taken as the ALLIANCE’s views on them.
As stated in the Independent Review of Adult Social Care, the National Care Service should ensure that everyone in Scotland gets the social care support they need to live their lives as they choose and to be active citizens. The National Care Service should enable us to work together by promoting and ensuring human rights, wellbeing, independent living and equity.
Read our response in full below.
End of page.
You may also like:
Could you help shape the future of Human Rights in Scotland? Apply to join the SNAP2 Leadership Panel
Continue readingThe UN ICESCR Committee has issued its recommendations and several reflect points made by the ALLIANCE and our members.
Continue readingCarers Scotland launches their State of Caring in Scotland 2024 research report.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE responds to the Equality, Human Rights, and Civil Justice Committee's inquiry into the the Public Sector Equality Duty.
Continue readingOur response calls for a human rights based approach to outcomes, and to consider how to strengthen the SHRC.
Continue readingA Scotland that Cares campaign calls on the Scottish Government to set a dedicated National Outcome on Care now.
Continue readingPublic Health Scotland have published a briefing on transport poverty and health inequalities.
Continue readingThe Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) has published a report on the state of economic, social and cultural rights in Scotland.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcomes the proposed strategy, though a Human Rights Bill is necessary for full effect.
Continue readingObesity Action Scotland wants to stop unhealthy food sponsorship at Scottish sports events including the 2026 Glasgow Commonwealth Games.
Continue readingResidents of Leith’s famous Banana Flats (Cables Wynd House) have launched their human rights monitoring report.
Continue readingThe Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC) report finds troubling failures in progress from institutionalisation to independent living.
Continue readingThe updated SPSO Principles demonstrate a positive shift towards putting people and their human rights at the centre of complaints handling.
Continue readingThe Mental Welfare Commission calls for urgent changes so people with learning disability and complex needs can leave hospital and flourish.
Continue readingMinister announces parts of the National Care Service Bill will be dropped due to a lack of compromise and support.
Continue readingAre you aged 55+, living in the UK, and interested in supporting new research?
Continue readingWe have submitted a parallel report to the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights for its examination of rights in the UK.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE welcome the aims of widening access to palliative care, but actions must be underpinned by resources and accountability.
Continue readingAutistic Knowledge Development and National Autistic Society Scotland celebrate the success of the Embrace Autism programme.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE wants to hear from you if you have experienced barriers to accessing Self-Directed Support.
Continue readingThe First Minister has reiterated his commitment to the continuation of Contact Scotland BSL.
Continue readingThe Policy and Public Affairs programme influenced government policy in many areas over 2024.
Continue readingRaising awareness of key areas of women’s health, challenging myths and stigma through positive dialogue, and lived experience forums.
Continue readingWhilst the draft Covenant is a positive start, it is unclear how it's aims will be realised in practice.
Continue readingWho Cares? Scotland publishes their third Lifelong Rights Issue Paper on Belonging and Connections.
Continue reading