PAPLS Committee’s findings from SDS enquiry
- Written by: — Senior Policy and Outcomes Officer
- Published: 13th March 2018

Colin reflects on the findings from the Public Audit and Post-Legislative Scrutiny Committee's enquiry into Self-directed Support.
In November 2017 the ALLIANCE gave evidence to the Public Audit and Post-Legislative Scrutiny Committee (this link will take you away from our website) (the Committee) alongside other representatives from the Third Sector and Health and Social Care Partnerships. Since then, the Committee’s convenor Jenny Marra MSP has written to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport to outline their findings from their inquiry into Self-directed Support (SDS). In her letter to the Cabinet Secretary, Shona Robison, Jenny Marra focussed on the main issues inhibiting the successful implementation of SDS across Scotland.
Looking first at the general progress of SDS implementation, while the Committee agreed with Audit Scotland’s findings, from their SDS 2017 Progress Report (this link will take you away from our website), that the intentions of SDS are being delivered in some local authorities, there is slow progression of a transformational change. During their evidence session, COSLA were challenged over the amount of resources required by local authorities to meet the needs of people in their area. Responding in a letter to the Committee (this link will take you away from our website), COSLA’s Chief Officer, John Wood, suggested that there needed to be a modelling exercise with the Scottish Government to analyse the implications for the future funding of social care.
Turning to the more specific issues affecting the roll-out of SDS, Marra addresses the lack of independent information and advocacy, which the ALLIANCE spoke to during the evidence session. Given that the Government announced a new round of funding for the third sector to offer support and information, the Committee advised the Government to consult with stakeholders on distribution of the fund. While the ALLIANCE supports this advice, we feel there is a role for local authorities to increase and improve the information given to people during the assessment process about the support organisations available to them.
The absence of data on SDS outcomes was highlighted by the Committee as a cause for concern and thus prompted the Government to detail their plans to improve monitoring of implementation. Here, the ALLIANCE sees a clear role for the third sector in providing an independent report on the state of SDS roll-out throughout Scotland as has previously been carried out by ourselves and Self Directed Support Scotland.
Perhaps the Committee’s most pressing issues were directed towards the approach taken by local authorities’ frontline staff and their leadership. Particularly, the lack of consistency between local authorities over what individual budgets can be used for was critiqued. In identifying that there is a tendency by some local authorities to be more prescriptive than others over how budgets can be used, the ALLIANCE supports the Committee’s suggestion that the Scottish Government should consider its role in encouraging greater leadership in implementing the intentions of the SDS Act.
Linked to this, is the joint responsibility the Committee believes that COSLA and the Scottish Government should be taking with respect to funding SDS. While the £9.8m of further investment, detailed in a letter to the committee (this link will take you away from our website), is welcomed, the ALLIANCE concurs with the Committee’s concern and believes that there should be a more comprehensive strategy to embed the principles of Self-directed Support across Scotland.
End of page.
You may also like:
Sustainable funding can unlock the transformative power of creative engagement for tackling stigma.
Continue readingTo build a positive culture of human rights, everyone needs to know and be aware of their rights.
Continue readingEveryone deserves a safe and affordable home - Scotland must act now to make housing a human right for all.
Continue reading'What Matters to You?' is a question that transforms live through kindness and compassion. Read the story of Napier House in Fife.
Continue readingHuman rights are the path to a fairer, stronger Scotland; each step we take today helps to shape our future.
Continue readingThe Charter of Rights for People who live with and experience issues around substance use is about to be launched.
Continue readingSimple GDP growth alone does not deliver a fair, human rights respecting society and public services.
Continue readingHeidi Tweedie, Jane Miller and Dr Patty Lozano-Casal reflect on the need to end mental health stigma and discrimination in healthcare.
Continue readingThe benefits of collaborative analysis approaches and why more should embark on this process.
Continue readingHilda Campbell shares COPE Scotland's thoughts and ideas for keeping well and improving your wellbeing during the winter months.
Continue readingAs the Self Management Network Scotland reaches 1,000 members, Joanne McCoy, Manager at MySelf-Management reflects on the network's value.
Continue readingJohn Watson, Associate Director of Stroke Association Scotland, shares how vital investment into stroke care is.
Continue readingInsecure, poor quality housing is making people ill and fuelling health inequalities in Scotland.
Continue readingDespite the recent concerns over the Scottish Human Rights Bill, the day felt insightful and optimistic.
Continue readingAfter gathering nominations to help identify an area, the Scottish Government has proposed a new National Park to be created in Galloway.
Continue readingLearn about the Partners in Integration programme delivered by Scottish Care to achieve a more cohesive and integrated care service.
Continue readingFuel poverty isn’t just an energy issue – it’s a public health issue that demands urgent attention.
Continue readingAt Glasgow’s Byres Community Hub, something special unfolds once a month on Fridays from 11 am to 1 pm.
Continue readingCOPE Scotland launch new campaign with resources to support the journey to increased confidence and self-belief.
Continue readingTom shares his journey with self management, since being diagnosed with epilepsy four years ago.
Continue readingRead about the Nystagmus Network's BBC Radio 4 charity appeal on 11 August and how this has raised awareness of the eye condition.
Continue readingRebecca's research into social connectedness highlights the importance of strong community networks and services in rural areas in Scotland.
Continue readingSoberBuzz give an overview of their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community Award.
Continue readingMoira Anderson Foundation give an overview of their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community.
Continue readingFinding Your Feet discuss their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community Award.
Continue reading