The power of Open Dialogue is hard to ignore
- Written by: — Assistant Director (Policy and Communications)
- Published: 12th February 2018

Andrew reflects on a new model for mental health support that could help break down power imbalances between service users and staff.
For a word which is used so often, power is incredibly difficult to define.
But as NHS Health Scotland point out in their briefing note on power and health and social care, “power exists in the relationships between people and groups of people, sometimes organised and sometimes not.”
One of our most common experiences of power is the relationship we all have with the experienced and knowledgeable professionals working in our health and social care system. For many this relationship can be tricky. One of the most common concerns expressed on Care Opinion is the feeling of being a number and not a person and that “the system” has disempowered people and left the expertise and experience they have of their own lives, feelings and conditions at the door.
Critics of the mental health system in Scotland suggest that it places too much emphasis on dealing with the short term diagnosis and treatment of a crisis, rather than placing the emphasis on long term, more sustainable approaches (this link will take you away from our website).
The Open Dialogue approach, the subject of the Health and Social Care Academy’s latest research report, is a model of support designed for people experiencing psychosis pioneered in Finland, seeks to change this dynamic, with impressive results. It is not a radical alternative – but more a shift in approach away from traditional psychiatry – placing the emphasis on discussion about the best way forward that includes people with mental health problems, families, friends, and professionals in designing solutions.
Key elements include immediate support within 24 hours of first contact, no set agenda for network discussions and crucially professionals are expected to share their feelings directly with the whole network, alongside those of family, friends and neighbours. Often this can include disagreements between professionals about the best way forward – but openness and honest creates a situation where everyone is equal in the decisions that follow.
These principles have the potential to fundamentally rebalance the power dynamic in a way that could be beneficial across all types of services. But it requires policy makers and practitioners to make difficult decisions for it to happen. After all, it could be a threat to existing professional roles, assessment and treatment models and loss of professional control.
This type of approach requires a level of bravery – and doesn’t come without risks. But we need transformative answers to difficult questions – and the best ones always rely on putting the expertise of people at the centre of the approach. In England, many NHS Trusts are setting up pilots with agreement to evaluate and deepen the evidence base.
In my view, it’s not the approach that matters, but breaking down the power imbalance that will make the biggest difference. In Scotland it’s time to reflect on whether we want to be part of creating a different path for the services of the future.
End of page.
You may also like:
Reflecting on key messages from the ACRC Symposium.
Continue readingCould parkrun make you or your community healthier and happier?
Continue readingGrace Beaumont looks to the Principles of Self Management as inspiration for this year’s Self Management Week awareness raising activity.
Continue readingNan McKay Community Hall is a welcoming space in Pollokshields where community, health, and wellbeing come together.
Continue readingLouise shares her thoughts on the need for a statutory right to lifelong, independent advocacy.
Continue readingALISS is supporting GCHSCP's work to help people live independent lives by connecting them to support in their local community.
Continue readingKairos Women+ share the vital foundations of their creative anti-stigma work with women.
Continue readingToo many carers simply cannot make ends meet, but a Minimum Income Guarantee could be the solution.
Continue readingNational Stalking Awareness Week 2025, from 21-25 April, will focus on healthcare professionals spotting the signs of stalking.
Continue readingCOPE Scotland have developed a suite of resources to rebuild confidence and self-belief, crucial components of mental wellbeing.
Continue readingCuts to disability payments by the UK government are all the more worrying for lack of information on devolution impacts in Scotland.
Continue readingTo improve outcomes for children and young people, we must consider how we can build on GIRFEC for the future.
Continue readingHow funding community-led participatory creative projects can shine a light on intersectional stigma
Maeve reflects on the Anti-Stigma Arts fund and how community-led projects can lead the way in tackling stigma.
Continue readingThe role of museums in promoting community engagement, health, and education was a major theme of the discussions throughout the day.
Continue readingAt the ALLIANCE we believe that accessibility is a gateway to human rights.
Continue readingLorraine Glass, Director at respectme, reflects on the vital work they do to reduce bullying and improve wellbeing.
Continue reading“Before, when I thought about what happened, something inside me was stuck. Now, after sharing my story I feel lighter, and more free”.
Continue readingSustainable funding can unlock the transformative power of creative engagement for tackling stigma.
Continue readingTo build a positive culture of human rights, everyone needs to know and be aware of their rights.
Continue readingEveryone deserves a safe and affordable home - Scotland must act now to make housing a human right for all.
Continue reading'What Matters to You?' is a question that transforms live through kindness and compassion. Read the story of Napier House in Fife.
Continue readingHuman rights are the path to a fairer, stronger Scotland; each step we take today helps to shape our future.
Continue readingThe Charter of Rights for People who live with and experience issues around substance use is about to be launched.
Continue readingSimple GDP growth alone does not deliver a fair, human rights respecting society and public services.
Continue readingHeidi Tweedie, Jane Miller and Dr Patty Lozano-Casal reflect on the need to end mental health stigma and discrimination in healthcare.
Continue reading