The impact of COVID-19 guidelines on young people living in care communities
- Written by: Anonymous
- Published: 13th August 2020
Parents of a young woman with learning disabilities voice concerns for their daughter due to lockdown guidelines for care communities.
When do healthy adults not in the designated clinically vulnerable health categories living in a COVID-19 free environment have to adhere to exactly the same guidelines as elderly people with multi-health issues living in care homes most affected by COVID-19? Answer when those adults have learning disabilities.
We are parents of a young adult living in a care community where the residents live in individual supported households, 6 or 7 residents per house with support staff who work in shifts. In addition to the residential accommodation the community runs workshops – pottery, gardening, bakery etc. for the residents and for students who attend daily. The community is defined as a Care Home and therefore must follow guidelines in place for care homes.
We understand that in the first months of the current crisis things had to move quickly and the most pressing issue was to contain the spread of the virus at all costs but now with the loosening of lockdown, it is time to consider each type of care environment and ensure appropriate and nuanced guidelines whilst containing the virus?
Healthy people with learning disabilities in care communities at the beginning or in the midst of their adult life, are being subject to exactly the same guidelines as those care homes catering to the elderly and those with compromising health issues.
In normal circumstances our daughter would come to the family home every second weekend, for family events and holidays. As things stand, we may only visit with her in the outdoors of the countryside surrounding the community and only one of us is allowed per visit of 30 minutes’ duration in the evening or at weekends. She has not been to the family home for almost 4 months.
As parents we can see that after 4 months this lack of connection with her family and the outside world is beginning to seriously damage her emotional and mental health. To avoid this situation worsening we would, of course, like to just bring her to her family home for a visit. However she would then, on her return to her home, have to isolate for 14 days, no matter if she tests negative for COVID-19. This length of quarantine would most surely have a detrimental impact to her wellbeing. What kind of choice is this?
As the country moves into phase 3 we are fully aware of how as a society we need to be extremely careful not to endanger the success so far but what is the difference in COVID-19 containment terms between a young student living in a communal flat with 5 or 6 others visiting their family home and a resident of a care community doing the same? Our daughter and others are being denied this basic right with no firm health reason underpinning it. It is draconian and unintentionally cruel, and we need urgent meaningful action. The possibility of long-term damage to communities like my daughter’s and its residents is very real.
We need urgent action to create holistic and compassionate guidelines for care communities recognizing the diversity of health issues, needs and care environments. We recognize that the need to contain the virus is paramount, but in this stage of loosening of lockdown the needs of this group of vulnerable citizens must not be ignored.
If this is a war against COVID-19 then residents of care communities for adults with learning disabilities are being seriously wounded by friendly fire.
End of page.
You may also like:
Kelly Muir reflects on the barriers for people with no recourse to public funds when accessing the right to health.
Continue readingSelf Management Programme Manager Grace reflects on the fifteenth anniversary of Gaun Yersel, the Self Management Strategy for Scotland.
Continue readingAutomated reminder emails to users have started, following the most recent technical improvements to ALISS.
Continue readingFor many the nightmare of Long Covid is something they live with every day.
Continue readingPromoting rights awareness through accessible information and the voice of lived experience.
Continue readingThe third sector’s economic contribution and development seems to be too often overlooked.
Continue readingDigital Assistant Director, Chris Mackie reflects how the lack of an appropriate sticker led to the destruction of medical records.
Continue reading"Because no one put a sticker on them."
Continue readingWhy it matters to you to participate in the public consultation on 'A draft outline Charter of Rights for People Affected by Substance Use'.
Continue readingDr Tony Robertson reflects on how we make the right to health a reality for everyone.
Continue readingOver 12 million people live with Congenital Heart Disease globally with a population of 20,000 in Scotland.
Continue readingRory Chapman (Development Officer) reflects on the What Matters to You National Networking Event
Continue readingGiving unique insights into individual's lives, experiences, needs, and sense of character.
Continue readingReflections on a Self Management Reflective Practice (SMRP) session, from a Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland Advice and Support Practitioner.
Continue readingLucy highlights some ALLIANCE human rights activity from this year and to mark Human Rights Day 2023.
Continue readingChief Executive of Scottish Care, Donald Macaskill, critically reflects on the Winter Preparedness Plan.
Continue readingCalum reflects on the Community Partnership Conference 2023 in Inverness, which was built on trusting relationships and partnership working.
Continue readingSelf Management Network Scotland members Foundation for Positive Mental Health on how their free app can help with workforce wellbeing.
Continue readingHannah Tweed asks, “what next?” and calls for action from Scottish Government on the findings of the National Audiology Review.
Continue reading"Modern football clubs have a responsibility to engage with and take care of the communities they represent".
Continue readingMark Ballard outlines writes that it is time for the Scottish Government to act on the National Audiology Review
Continue readingCalum reflects on the Design HOPES launch event and the value that the third sector can add to the potentially world-leading project.
Continue readingSenior Development Officer for the Children and Young People Programme reflects on the current nature of funding in the sector.
Continue readingDirect support to disabled people, people living with long term conditions and unpaid carers would be wiser use of funds.
Continue readingThe essential role integration has to play in delivering the Scottish Government's Value Based Health and Care Action Plan.
Continue reading