The power of Open Dialogue is hard to ignore
- Written by: — Assistant Director (Policy and Communications)
- Published: 28th August 2018
Andrew reflects on a new model for mental health support that could help break down power imbalances between service users and staff.
For a word which is used so often, power is incredibly difficult to define.
But as NHS Health Scotland point out in their excellent briefing note (this link will take you away from our website) on power and health and social care, “power exists in the relationships between people and groups of people, sometimes organised and sometimes not.”
One of our most common experiences of power is the relationship we all have with the experienced and knowledgeable professionals working in our health and social care system. For many this relationship can be tricky. One of the most common concerns expressed on Care Opinion is the feeling of being a number and not a person and that “the system” has disempowered people and left the expertise and experience they have of their own lives, feelings and conditions at the door.
Critics of the mental health system in Scotland suggest that it places too much emphasis on dealing with the short term diagnosis and treatment of a crisis, rather than placing the emphasis on long term, more sustainable approaches (this link will take you away from our website).
The Open Dialogue approach, the subject of the Health and Social Care Academy’s latest research report, is a model of support designed for people experiencing psychosis pioneered in Finland, seeks to change this dynamic, with impressive results. It is not a radical alternative – but more a shift in approach away from traditional psychiatry – placing the emphasis on discussion about the best way forward that includes people with mental health problems, families, friends, and professionals in designing solutions.
Key elements include immediate support within 24 hours of first contact, no set agenda for network discussions and crucially professionals are expected to share their feelings directly with the whole network, alongside those of family, friends and neighbours. Often this can include disagreements between professionals about the best way forward – but openness and honest creates a situation where everyone is equal in the decisions that follow.
These principles have the potential to fundamentally rebalance the power dynamic in a way that could be beneficial across all types of services. But it requires policy makers and practitioners to make difficult decisions for it to happen. After all, it could be a threat to existing professional roles, assessment and treatment models and loss of professional control.
This type of approach requires a level of bravery – and doesn’t come without risks. But we need transformative answers to difficult questions – and the best ones always rely on putting the expertise of people at the centre of the approach. In England, many NHS Trusts are setting up pilots with agreement to evaluate and deepen the evidence base.
In my view, it’s not the approach that matters, but breaking down the power imbalance that will make the biggest difference. In Scotland it’s time to reflect on whether we want to be part of creating a different path for the services of the future.
5 September 2018 will see experts and people with lived experience of mental health crises gather to discuss how Open Dialogue can benefit those in Scotland.
If you wish to attend the event, or if you have any questions about the event or Open Dialogue, then please contact academy@alliance-scotland.org.uk . The closing date for registering for the event is 31st August 2018.
End of page.
You may also like:
‘This is such a beautiful way to bring in an element that's vital to someone's happiness.’ Professional Care Partner.
Continue readingA lived experience perspective is needed to develop services and amplify the voices of unpaid carers of all ages in Highland.
Continue readingKelly Muir reflects on the barriers for people with no recourse to public funds when accessing the right to health.
Continue readingSelf Management Programme Manager Grace reflects on the fifteenth anniversary of Gaun Yersel, the Self Management Strategy for Scotland.
Continue readingAutomated reminder emails to users have started, following the most recent technical improvements to ALISS.
Continue readingFor many the nightmare of Long Covid is something they live with every day.
Continue readingPromoting rights awareness through accessible information and the voice of lived experience.
Continue readingThe third sector’s economic contribution and development seems to be too often overlooked.
Continue readingDigital Assistant Director, Chris Mackie reflects how the lack of an appropriate sticker led to the destruction of medical records.
Continue reading"Because no one put a sticker on them."
Continue readingWhy it matters to you to participate in the public consultation on 'A draft outline Charter of Rights for People Affected by Substance Use'.
Continue readingDr Tony Robertson reflects on how we make the right to health a reality for everyone.
Continue readingOver 12 million people live with Congenital Heart Disease globally with a population of 20,000 in Scotland.
Continue readingRory Chapman (Development Officer) reflects on the What Matters to You National Networking Event
Continue readingGiving unique insights into individual's lives, experiences, needs, and sense of character.
Continue readingReflections on a Self Management Reflective Practice (SMRP) session, from a Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland Advice and Support Practitioner.
Continue readingLucy highlights some ALLIANCE human rights activity from this year and to mark Human Rights Day 2023.
Continue readingChief Executive of Scottish Care, Donald Macaskill, critically reflects on the Winter Preparedness Plan.
Continue readingCalum reflects on the Community Partnership Conference 2023 in Inverness, which was built on trusting relationships and partnership working.
Continue readingSelf Management Network Scotland members Foundation for Positive Mental Health on how their free app can help with workforce wellbeing.
Continue readingHannah Tweed asks, “what next?” and calls for action from Scottish Government on the findings of the National Audiology Review.
Continue reading"Modern football clubs have a responsibility to engage with and take care of the communities they represent".
Continue readingMark Ballard outlines writes that it is time for the Scottish Government to act on the National Audiology Review
Continue readingCalum reflects on the Design HOPES launch event and the value that the third sector can add to the potentially world-leading project.
Continue readingSenior Development Officer for the Children and Young People Programme reflects on the current nature of funding in the sector.
Continue reading