Launching the reform of adult social care
- Written by: Hannah Tweed — Senior Policy Officer
- Published: 28th June 2019

Hannah reflects on the Scottish Government’s new vision statement for the reform of adult social care in Scotland.
Following an extensive consultation period, in June 2019 the Scottish Government launched their vision statement and programme framework (this link will take you away from our website) for the reform of adult social care.
Cumulatively, these documents are the product of over three years of consultation and discussion. They span the continued implementation of Self-directed Support (SDS) across Scotland, and the Carers (Scotland) Act 2016. They’re intended to outline the future of adult social care in Scotland, across a complex landscape of provision and practice.
The proposed vision for adult social care (including support for carers) paints an attractive picture: person-led, directed by human rights approaches and principles, and centred on quality of life. There’s an explicit statement that investment in social care support should match ‘its important role in this whole system of supports and services’. However, these aspirations must be viewed within the context of comparable policy and its implementation. SDS, the implementation of which is mentioned as a key ‘enabler’ for these reforms, is an obvious example.
Over the last six months, the ALLIANCE and Self Directed Support Scotland have been carrying out research (funded by the Scottish Government) into people’s experiences of accessing and using SDS. The initial findings from the ‘My Support My Choice’ project show close alignment between what people want from social care and many aspects of the ‘shared vision’. The reform documents make explicit statements about the need for ‘investment in Scotland’s people, society, and economy’. They focus on people’s quality of life and citizenship, including the ‘right to family life and for carers to have breaks and a life beyond caring’.
Yet these statements, although responsive to concerns within the care sector, are offered alongside consistent reductions in the budget for the SDS programme (this link will take you away from our website). Funding for SDS has fallen from £10.5 million in the 2017-2018 Draft Budget to £9.2 million in the 2018-2019 Draft Budget –an estimated real value of £8.99 million, allowing for inflation. The Scottish Human Rights Commission estimate that the latter equates to a 33.6% reduction in funding between 2015-2016 and 2019-2020 (this link will take you away from our website). This reduction took place while SDS was still being implemented across Scotland as the new mode of delivering social care. As such, detailed information on funding models is a key next step for the effective implementation of the reform of adult social care.
Similarly, the reforms state that ‘responding to crisis’ will be the exception rather than the rule in terms of how people first access social care support. Information will be provided for informed decision-making, and people will be treated with respect and kindness throughout. The reforms also respond to widely reported concerns about parity of social care experience, stating that people will ‘get the same quality and level of support across Scotland even if it is provided differently in different areas.’
These are admirable goals and match the ideals of SDS legislation and wider engagement with human rights. In practice, our research findings so far show that it’s increasingly common for people to only get help once they are in crisis, with eligibility criteria being tightened in response to budgetary constraints. Furthermore, there is significant variance in people’s access to social care across different local authorities (and even across different localities within a local authority area).
The reform of adult social care demonstrates engagement with many of the key concerns of people accessing social care and their families, care providers, and the public and third sectors. However, the sharp contrast between these ideals and current practice offers a significant challenge to effective implementation.
Concerns about a gap between legislation and practice have been raised repeatedly by respondents to ‘My Support My Choice’, and by our members. Going forward, the ALLIANCE will continue to highlight the realities of people’s experience of social care. We welcome the chance to facilitate public conversations and detailed discussion of implementation plans for the reform of adult social care, centred on people’s lived experience.
Further reading:
Programme Framework (this link will take you away from our website)
Summary Report of Discussion Paper Responses (this link will take you away from our website)
Self-directed Support Implementation Plan 2019-2020 (this link will take you away from our website)
End of page.
You may also like:
Sustainable funding can unlock the transformative power of creative engagement for tackling stigma.
Continue readingTo build a positive culture of human rights, everyone needs to know and be aware of their rights.
Continue readingEveryone deserves a safe and affordable home - Scotland must act now to make housing a human right for all.
Continue reading'What Matters to You?' is a question that transforms live through kindness and compassion. Read the story of Napier House in Fife.
Continue readingHuman rights are the path to a fairer, stronger Scotland; each step we take today helps to shape our future.
Continue readingThe Charter of Rights for People who live with and experience issues around substance use is about to be launched.
Continue readingSimple GDP growth alone does not deliver a fair, human rights respecting society and public services.
Continue readingHeidi Tweedie, Jane Miller and Dr Patty Lozano-Casal reflect on the need to end mental health stigma and discrimination in healthcare.
Continue readingThe benefits of collaborative analysis approaches and why more should embark on this process.
Continue readingHilda Campbell shares COPE Scotland's thoughts and ideas for keeping well and improving your wellbeing during the winter months.
Continue readingAs the Self Management Network Scotland reaches 1,000 members, Joanne McCoy, Manager at MySelf-Management reflects on the network's value.
Continue readingJohn Watson, Associate Director of Stroke Association Scotland, shares how vital investment into stroke care is.
Continue readingInsecure, poor quality housing is making people ill and fuelling health inequalities in Scotland.
Continue readingDespite the recent concerns over the Scottish Human Rights Bill, the day felt insightful and optimistic.
Continue readingAfter gathering nominations to help identify an area, the Scottish Government has proposed a new National Park to be created in Galloway.
Continue readingLearn about the Partners in Integration programme delivered by Scottish Care to achieve a more cohesive and integrated care service.
Continue readingFuel poverty isn’t just an energy issue – it’s a public health issue that demands urgent attention.
Continue readingAt Glasgow’s Byres Community Hub, something special unfolds once a month on Fridays from 11 am to 1 pm.
Continue readingCOPE Scotland launch new campaign with resources to support the journey to increased confidence and self-belief.
Continue readingTom shares his journey with self management, since being diagnosed with epilepsy four years ago.
Continue readingRead about the Nystagmus Network's BBC Radio 4 charity appeal on 11 August and how this has raised awareness of the eye condition.
Continue readingRebecca's research into social connectedness highlights the importance of strong community networks and services in rural areas in Scotland.
Continue readingSoberBuzz give an overview of their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community Award.
Continue readingMoira Anderson Foundation give an overview of their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community.
Continue readingFinding Your Feet discuss their work and what it means to them to be nominated for the Self Management in the Community Award.
Continue reading