Mental Welfare Commission publishes two reports for consideration by the Scottish Mental Health Law Review
- Area of Work: The ALLIANCE
- Type: News Item
- Published: 20th July 2021
The reports outline new analysis on advance statements and significantly impaired decision making ability.
The Mental Welfare Commission has published two reports for the Scottish Mental Health Law Review to consider as part of its current work (this link will take you away from our website).
The first of the two reports shows very low use of advance statements by people who are detained for treatment and who are visited by doctors appointed by the Mental Welfare Commission. An advance statement is written by a person when they are well, setting out the care and treatment they would prefer or would dislike should they become mentally unwell again in the future. While advanced statements were introduced in the 2003 Mental Health Act as important safeguards for individuals, the new analysis shows that only 6.6% of people being detained for treatment under the Act over a three and a half year period had written an advance statement. The report makes recommendations to improve uptake of advance statement.
The second report is a research paper, focusing on one of the criteria – significantly impaired decision making ability (SIDMA) – used when doctors consider that a person requires compulsory treatment. SIDMA is a concept unique to Scots Law, introduced in the 2003 Act as part of efforts to reduce discrimination and incorporate greater respect for patient autonomy. The new report finds poor practice in recording and describing the presence of SIDMA in almost every one of 100 compulsory treatment forms examined. While it is not a legal requirement to record this detail, the Mental Welfare Commission believes it is important to do so in practice.
Read the report on advance statements (this link will take you away from our website).
End of page.
You may also like:
You can get involved by responding to their call for evidence or joining their community of interest.
Continue readingBy sharing your views, you are directly taking part in changing things for the better for young women and girls.
Continue readingDedicated to supporting disabled young people aged 16–25 achieve positive futures.
Continue readingDigiKnowVember is Renfrewshire’s annual celebration of digital inclusion.
Continue readingThe 2027 GSK IMPACT Awards and GSK Community Health programme to support small charities are now open for applications.
Continue readingPriorities concerning gambling advertising from ScotRGH's latest Roundtable event.
Continue readingAnnual workforce survey now open for social care services employing registered nurses
Continue readingFor the first time, SEMTSF is localising across Scotland, bringing the summit experience to Aberdeen, Glasgow, Fife, and Edinburgh.
Continue readingThe University of Edinburgh is conducting the SCOPE+ research study on post-abortion contraception, and wants to hear from many voices.
Continue readingHave your say on how to create a more inclusive transport system for everyone.
Continue readingYou’re Connected: new partnership with The Melting Pot offers exclusive benefits to ALLIANCE members
Access discounts to The Melting Pot’s co-working community and flexible workspaces.
Continue readingHave your say on the role of Vision Rehabilitation Assistants.
Continue readingThe survey is part of research to improve the lives of Scottish LGBTQ+ communities.
Continue readingGeneral Pharmaceutical Council are raising awareness of buying medicines from fake online pharmacies and other illegal sellers.
Continue readingSocial support group for adults with any level of Deafness or tinnitus.
Continue readingFamily Fund are calling for Scottish Government to take bold action to reduce digital exclusion amongst families with a disabled child.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE celebrates five years since the launch of the Discover Digital Guide and wants you to help shape its refresh.
Continue readingObesity Action Scotland are hosting a focus group to hear your views on GLP-1 medicines.
Continue readingThis is your chance to help inform the Community Knowledge Matter (CKM) network.
Continue readingThe Gambling Harm and Mental Health fund is open for applicants
Continue reading#TryAToolTuesday raises awareness of free and trusted apps and resources that help people improve and manage their health and wellbeing.
Continue readingLast call for nominations for the Social Enterprise Awards Scotland.
Continue readingParticipate in a study into family or carer outcomes after critical illness (FOCUS), led by the University of Cambridge.
Continue readingLast call to nominate for the Frontline Awards 2026.
Continue readingRead our published response on the voting experiences of people who are Deaf, Deafblind, or who have Visual Impairments.
Continue reading