Mental Welfare Commission publishes two reports for consideration by the Scottish Mental Health Law Review
- Area of Work: The ALLIANCE
- Type: News Item
- Published: 20th July 2021
The reports outline new analysis on advance statements and significantly impaired decision making ability.
The Mental Welfare Commission has published two reports for the Scottish Mental Health Law Review to consider as part of its current work (this link will take you away from our website).
The first of the two reports shows very low use of advance statements by people who are detained for treatment and who are visited by doctors appointed by the Mental Welfare Commission. An advance statement is written by a person when they are well, setting out the care and treatment they would prefer or would dislike should they become mentally unwell again in the future. While advanced statements were introduced in the 2003 Mental Health Act as important safeguards for individuals, the new analysis shows that only 6.6% of people being detained for treatment under the Act over a three and a half year period had written an advance statement. The report makes recommendations to improve uptake of advance statement.
The second report is a research paper, focusing on one of the criteria – significantly impaired decision making ability (SIDMA) – used when doctors consider that a person requires compulsory treatment. SIDMA is a concept unique to Scots Law, introduced in the 2003 Act as part of efforts to reduce discrimination and incorporate greater respect for patient autonomy. The new report finds poor practice in recording and describing the presence of SIDMA in almost every one of 100 compulsory treatment forms examined. While it is not a legal requirement to record this detail, the Mental Welfare Commission believes it is important to do so in practice.
Read the report on advance statements (this link will take you away from our website).
End of page.
You may also like:
Participate in a study into family or carer outcomes after critical illness (FOCUS), led by the University of Cambridge.
Continue readingLast call to nominate for the Frontline Awards 2026.
Continue readingRead our published response on the voting experiences of people who are Deaf, Deafblind, or who have Visual Impairments.
Continue readingComplete this consultation if you access optometry services, support people to access eye care services, or are an eye care professional.
Continue readingFirst FIFA tournament to have sign language interpretation broadcasts for all matches.
Continue readingThe annual survey by Carers UK helps to shape campaigns and policy work, based on the experiences of unpaid carers.
Continue readingThe Self Management Fund has awarded new grants to 23 organisations across Scotland
Continue readingTheresa Campbell, MSc Psychology student, is investigating the impact of deprivation following cancer treatment.
Continue readingLived experience participation in local decision making affected: "It's draining, I have a chronic condition, hence why I'm going to stop"
Continue readingThe Practice Learning Review Consultation will remain open until 23 July 2026
Continue readingRead our updated members handbook to discover the benefits of your ALLIANCE membership.
Continue readingThe MyCare app is available in the App Store and Play Store.
Continue readingMulti-year funding was at the centre of the Scottish Parliament debate on a Third Sector Partnership Agreement
Continue readingApply for this highly regarded leadership development offer from Leading to Change and PSD Scotland.
Continue readingThe Self Management Programme is changing to focus on the Fund, share learning, and support better health and wellbeing in Scotland.
Continue readingTogethers' new training and consultancy offers are now live.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE joins 54 signatories in calling for accessible news and equal access to information for all.
Continue readingRead the full response to the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s (EHRC) Code of Practice
Continue readingA new app from the Scottish Association for Supported Employment (SUSE) for helping people stay well in work
Continue readingFree self management and wellbeing resource for everyone helping young people with their wellbeing.
Continue readingThe date for this year's DiGiTal Get Together has been announced
Continue readingWe have published our conference report from our annual conference Hope to Action as we look to the future and the work still to be done.
Continue readingNew guidance supports Audiology services to design and develop clinical peer review schemes to support quality assurance.
Continue readingRegister for this paid Advisory Panel opportunity
Continue readingTake a short survey to share your experiences
Continue reading