ALLIANCE responds to Social Security Amendment Bill calls for views
- Area of Work: Policy and Research
- Type: News Item
- Published: 10th January 2024
Proposals to put the Scottish Child Payment on a firmer statutory footing and enhance choice and accountability are welcome.
Following the publication of the Social Security (Amendment) Bill, the ALLIANCE have responded to calls for views from the Social Justice and Social Security and the Finance and Public Administration Committees on the bill’s proposals and accompanying financial memorandum. We submitted a response to the Scottish Government’s pre-legislative consultation on the Bill, and consider that many of the proposals align closely with our recommendations.
After certain powers relating to social security were devolved to Scotland, the Social Security Scotland (Act) 2018 provided a strong yet flexible framework for the delivery of devolved payments. This flexibility has been used by the Scottish Government to make some much-needed changes to how the social security system works, in particular explicitly embedding the principle that social security is a human right.
There remain however improvements that can be made to the system. Although many of these would relate to secondary legislation or to operational policies, we recognise the need for some changes in primary legislation. In our response, the ALLIANCE:
- Welcomed the proposal to establish “childhood assistance” as its own category of payment, allowing greater flexibility in delivering the Scottish Child Payment than current “top up” arrangements.
- Welcomed the introduction of more choice and accountability within the system, including the ability to withdraw a re-determination request and to challenge liability for overpayment.
- Cautioned that proposals relating to fraud and error only be applied where strictly necessary, and that individuals are reminded of their right to independent advocacy and/or advice in such circumstances.
- Called for the establishment of a successor to the Disability and Carers Benefits Expert Advisory Group (DACBEAG) to provide independent advice on social security on a permanent basis.
- Urged a wider review of disability and carer payments after the end of the safe and secure transition, and to rapidly progress work towards a Minimum Income Guarantee.
You can find the full responses via the resource links below.
End of page.
You may also like:
Regardless of who is First Minister, there must be progress on social care reform, human rights, and health inequalities.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE has published a report on people's experiences of accessible information around Self-directed Support and social care.
Continue readingAdapting to climate change is essential, but pressures on sectors including the third sector are currently limiting the capacity to engage.
Continue readingThe Bill should explicitly embed the social model of disability, intersectionality, human rights based and person centred approaches.
Continue readingDisabled people continue to face heightened challenges associated with higher energy bills, including risks to health and wellbeing.
Continue readingAmendments to the Scotland Act are necessary to ensure the Scottish Parliament can fully incorporate human rights in devolved areas.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE has responded to the Scottish Government's consultation on the Good Food Nation Plan and Specified Functions.
Continue readingALLIANCE statement on the negative impact of economic policy and public finance decision-making
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE responds to Health Improvement Scotland's survey on the proposed National Healthcare Standards.
Continue readingWe want to hear from you on what you think about our draft response to the LDAN Bill, and what else you would like included.
Continue readingRead the full report on Anti-Seizure Medicines (ASMs) prescribed to females aged 0 to 54, and pregnant women in Scotland.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE is pleased to publish a visual resource in support of the Scottish Government’s Women’s Health Plan.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE has responded to the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee inquiry on the Suicide Prevention Strategy 2022-2032
Continue readingALLIANCE signs joint letter to Health, Social Care and Sport Committee on Minimum Unit Pricing (MUP)
The ALLIANCE have signed a joint letter urging the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee to retain and uprate MUP for alcohol.
Continue readingThe Scottish Government wants to better understand how care experience survey data is currently used.
Continue readingSupport a research project that seeks to improve services and support post-stroke for people in deprived / ethnically diverse communities.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE and Scottish Government have produced several resources on premenstrual syndrome, in support of the Women's Health Plan.
Continue readingSign a petition to the Scottish Government to make chronic kidney disease a clinical priority in Scotland.
Continue readingThe response highlights the importance of Commissioners to upholding rights, but recognises the risk of fragmentation.
Continue readingThe report focuses on Health and Social Care Partnerships’ (HSCPs) strategic plans and annual reports.
Continue readingThe ALLIANCE and Scottish Government have produced several resources on endometriosis, in support of the Women's Health Plan.
Continue readingALLIANCE Chief Officer, Sara Redmond, comments on the Scottish Parliament voting in favour of the National Care Service (NCS) Bill.
Continue readingThe Scottish Food Coalition encourages people to host a Kitchen Table talk so everyone can have a say on the Good Food Nation Plan.
Continue readingWe want to hear from ALLIANCE members on what you think should be in our 2024 General Election Manifesto.
Continue readingBriefing highlights key recommendations and concerns ahead of the National Care Service Bill Stage 1 debate.
Continue reading